So you call a sectional. You know, the thing where you pull just the clarinets or just the trombones to work on a specific section because they need extra help.
Good plan, right? Focused rehearsal. Time to drill. Get the problem fixed.
Except you get in the room and half the kids are on their phones. One kid is literally sleeping against the wall. Someone's talking to their friend about what they had for lunch. And you're standing there thinking "why did I even set this up?"
This has been the most frustrating part of my entire career as a director. Not the hard music. Not the logistics. Getting my students to actually LISTEN during sectionals. Because sectionals don't work if nobody's listening.
And yeah, I've had students who just... didn't get it. Didn't understand why we were there. Didn't understand that sectional time was precious and limited and expensive in terms of everyone's schedule.
I've wasted so much sectional time over the years. I'm not even gonna lie. And I'm here to tell you that you don't have to do that.
Why Sectionals Fail
Okay, so first thing: most sectionals fail because students don't understand what they're there for.
You pull a section and say "we need to work on this passage." And kids are like... okay? They show up physically but mentally they're somewhere else. They don't get that this is special focused time. They think it's just like regular rehearsal but smaller.
It's not the same thing. Regular rehearsal is about the whole ensemble. Sectionals are about getting really specific, really deep, really focused on one thing.
Most of your students have never been in a real sectional before high school. They don't know what to expect. They don't know what they're supposed to do. They just know they had to leave their other class or come in after school and now they're sitting in a practice room.
And if you don't set expectations? They'll just do whatever they want.
I learned this the hard way. I had sectionals that were basically just chaos. Kids talking, not focusing, going through the motions. And I was wondering why nobody was improving. Turns out? They weren't actually engaging with the material.
Setting The Expectation Upfront
Okay, so here's what changed for me. I started being really deliberate about what a sectional is and what it's for.
I tell my students: "Sectional time is different from regular rehearsal. We're focusing on one thing. Everyone plays. Everyone listens. If you're not playing, you're listening to help someone else fix their part."
That's it. That's the rule. You're either playing or you're actively listening. There's no sitting in the corner on your phone. There's no zoning out.
And I'm serious about it. If someone's not following the rule, I stop. "Hey, everyone listen." Then I explain what we're fixing and why. Then we go again.
The first few sectionals are gonna feel weird because kids aren't used to this level of focus. But after like two or three, it becomes normal. They get it.
The Listening Part Is Actually The Whole Thing
Here's what I realized: the actual listening during sectionals is more important than what I'm saying.
Like, I can talk about intonation all day long. But if your students aren't actually listening to each other's intonation, nothing changes.
So I make sure that during sectionals, we're listening. A lot. I'll play a measure. Have everyone listen. Then I'll ask "what did you hear?" What was out of tune? What was too loud? What was the problem?
Your students need to develop an ear for what good sounds like and what needs to be fixed. You can't develop that ear if you're not listening.
I do this thing where I'll have my section play something and then I'll have them sit in silence for like 30 seconds and just think about what they heard. Not talk. Just listen internally to the sound that's still ringing in their ears.
It sounds weird. But it works. They start actually hearing themselves. They start understanding what they did wrong without me telling them.
Breaking The "Just Reading Notes" Habit
This is huge. A lot of students come into band thinking that the job is to read the notes correctly. That's it. Notes are right, you're done.
But that's not music. That's not even close to music.
In sectionals, you're trying to get them to understand that it's not about notes. It's about sound. It's about listening. It's about responding to what you hear around you.
So I'll do sectionals where I specifically say "don't worry about the notes being perfect. I want you to focus on listening to the person next to you and matching their sound."
That's hard for some kids because they're used to being graded on whether they get the notes right. But in sectionals, you're trying to shift that mentality.
I had a clarinet section that was really focused on note accuracy but they sounded terrible together. No blend. No cohesion. So I had them work on just listening to each other. Not thinking about their own part. Just listening.
It took like three sectionals, but suddenly they sounded like a section. Not perfect, but like an actual musical unit instead of four people playing at the same time.
Making It Actually Matter
Real talk: if sectionals feel optional to students, they're not gonna listen. They're gonna check out.
So I make sectionals matter. I include section attendance in their grade. Not as punishment, but just as "this is part of your grade in band." You miss a sectional without a good reason, that's a zero.
I also give them something specific to work on. Not just "let's rehearse." Specific goals. "Today we're fixing the intonation on measures 15-22." "We're working on blend in the second movement." Specific.
And I check on the work. At the next full rehearsal, I'll hear that section and think "yeah, they improved on that." And I acknowledge it. "I heard that intonation work from last week's sectional. That's way better."
Students need to see that sectionals matter. That they're not just busy work. That the work they do in sectionals actually shows up in the full band.
The Phone Thing
Okay, I'm gonna be real. Phones are the enemy of sectionals. If your students have their phones out, you've lost them.
I'm not even gonna let them bring phones into the sectional. Phones stay in backpacks. Done.
I know this sounds harsh, but it actually works. When phones aren't an option, students engage differently. They listen better. They focus better.
And honestly, it's only like an hour. They can survive an hour without checking their phone.
One time I had a student who was really resistant to the no-phone rule. And I just talked to them about it. "Look, during this one hour, I need your full attention. Not because I'm trying to be mean. Because sectionals only work if you're actually present."
They got it. And they became one of my best listeners in sectionals because they actually understood what we were trying to do.
When You Need Help Changing The Culture
Real talk: if you're trying to shift your entire program's culture around listening and engagement during sectionals, that's not a small thing. That's a big mindset shift for a lot of students.
If you're struggling with how to actually implement this, or if you've tried some stuff and it's not working, getting outside perspective helps. A music education consultant can come in, listen to your sectionals, understand your specific culture, and help you think through how to actually make listening and focused work a normal part of your program.
Dr. Ward Miller work with directors on program culture and rehearsal approaches. Having someone come in and help you think through how to structure sectionals so they're actually effective? That can really change things.
But honestly, it starts with you setting the expectation that sectional time is different. That listening is the job. That showing up is only half of it—actually being present is the other half.
The Payoff
Here's what I love about a good sectional: the moment when you see the lightbulb go on. When a student realizes "oh, I can hear that I'm flat." Or "I can hear how my sound blends with theirs."
That's the whole point. You're developing musicians who can hear, not just readers who can follow notes.
Once you break the bad habit of sectionals being just going-through-the-motions time, and you actually make them focused listening time? Your whole program improves.
Your sections sound better. Your full band sounds better. Your students understand music better.
It takes some work to get there. But it's worth it.
Start with one sectional. Set clear expectations about listening. See what happens. Your students might surprise you.
Top comments (0)